In 1989 Bob Kunst, director of Cure AIDS Now (the Miami organization
lauded by Peter Jennings’ TV series AIDS Quarterly, as
the most effective community-based AIDS organization in a state
third-hardest hit by the disease), was invited to the first
International Vatican Conference on AIDS. The previous year in Miami,
Pope John Paul II evaded a reporter’s question "Is AIDS God’s
judgment against homosexuals?" by replying that it is not easy to
know God’s intentions.
The Pope could, in a compassionate and civilized fashion, have laid
the entire matter to rest by saying, "No, such an idea runs
contrary to the kind of God I worship." But such was not the case.
The same day the Vatican newspaper called AIDS "nature’s
sanction" against immorality, CNN showed Bob Kunst
suggesting that the pope "shape up or ship out" of Miami.
Perhaps because his AIDS organization was on a list, or because
Vatican organizers never saw the CNN report, Kunst
received his invite to the Vatican AIDS conference. Once inside the holy
site, he offered immediate commentaries to the press. "The Catholic
Church," Kunst charged, "is so heavily into the condoms verses
abstinence debate, they’re really behind what’s happening. My
questions to church leaders are very simple. Where’s the cure? Where’s
the cure? Where’s the money for these things to happen? You are
ignoring these questions."
Kunst carried his message, "Cure AIDS Now," and pressed it
in the form of a button into the pope’s hand. It was expected that the
thousand scientists, church officials, theologians, and health workers
invited to the conference would greet one another with the usual serene
pleasantries. Thanks to Kunst and about forty-nine others, Time
called the conference "a tense meeting" and a
"ruckus," reporting that the hoped-for calm was
"disrupted by dissident caucuses and angry charges and counter
charges."
Bob Kunst was at the center of the fray. The media quoted him
addressing Archbishop Angelini, "This is the worst conference I’ve
ever attended. It has been three days of gay bashing." Kunst had
shot a flaming arrow into a Citadel of Darkness while the whole world
watched. (from The Gay Agenda: pages 138-39)
We who are members of gay and lesbian communities have long warned
that AIDS would soon devastate the straight communities as well, and,
because of our experiences, we know best how to make clear the horror of
AIDS and how to struggle for its elimination. The New York Health
Department’s projection of 100,000 AIDS death in the state by 1997
meant nothing to those like Mary Cummins, who insisted health
professionals sign loyalty oaths pledging, if they addressed classes, to
stress abstinence as the only answer to AIDS. Her name and that of the
(late) John Cardinal O’Connor, who gave her moral support, should be
noted when anguished parents collapse in despair as teen body counts
rise.
The Roman Catholic Church works at cross-purposes with itself. While
its chiefs disallow life-prolonging condoms, Catholic volunteers help
those in the terminal stages of AIDS to prepare for death. In many
cases, people dying from AIDS give their last monies to a church that
provides them with hospices and shelters built from necessity because of
the very anti-gay prejudices that the church encourages. Lying on cots
in these shelters, the dying faithful are served their last suppers by
strangers because many ‘virtuous’ Catholic families scornfully
reject their sons and daughters. (from The Gay Agenda:
pages 139-40)
Pope John Paul II, an ultraconservative in collusion with Protestant
fundamentalists, acts politically to stir up international opposition to
condoms. In the age of AIDS, an orthodox clergy would give (unless
ecclesiastical pipe dreams of premarital chastity become, for all
people, a reality) green lights to the deadly virus, causing mass
infections. Opposition by fundamentalists to abortion and birth control
leaves large parts of the world unprotected against the crisis of
overpopulation, now recognized by all but themselves. Mass starvation
and irreparable damage to the environment are the result. (from The
Gay Agenda: page 53).
Pope John Paul II made reference to the scriptural death penalties
for homosexuals in a 1986 letter:
"In Leviticus 18:22 and 20: 13, in
the course of describing the conditions necessary for belonging to the
Chosen People, the author excludes from the People of God those who
behave in a homosexual fashion."
A letter from the Vatican, intercepted and published in the Washington
Post, ordered American bishops to oppose legislation that
promotes civil rights for gay men and lesbians, labeling homosexuality,
in opposition to the American Psychiatric Association’s assessment,
"an objective disorder." The Post said That the
Roman Catholic Church has declared its support "for discrimination
against gay people in such areas as public housing, family, health
benefits, and the hiring of teachers, coaches and military
personnel." The Vatican, it is reported, insinuates that
homosexuals are mentally ill and insists that the denial of rights to
gays will promote family values. "The church has the
responsibility," says the letter, "to promote public morality
of the entire civil society on the basis of fundamental moral values.
The rights to housing and employment," continues to missive, are
not absolute, and employment, it says curiously, is "a
privilege." . (from The Gay Agenda: pages 56-57).
The Roman Church has long opposed "artificial" birth
control methods by calling them incentives to promiscuity. Even the
arrival of death dealing sexually-transmitted diseases has failed to
soften that opposition. Fundamentalist Protestants link arms with
Vatican policy makers on this issue, not only assuring that there will
be no distribution of condoms to sexually overactive teens, but
refusing, through their influence on many school boards, the right of
teachers to mention condoms in sex education classes. County school
boards under fundamentalist influences backed the Vatican in the matter
just as AIDS was spreading among adolescents.
The response to the AIDS crisis has been criminally sidetracked by
the need to stand up to fundamentalist pressures about condoms.
Community leaders have been slow to face AIDS as the number one killer
of young women (ages 25-29) in New York. And it is not taking smaller
towns much time to catch up with this staggering statistic. But with the
average time of AIDS incubation (five to ten years) we can look forward
to today’s youths dying like flies within the next decade. Will
prudish religionists send them to their deaths from AIDS? Will we then
think kindly of anti-sex "religious" crusades, as respectable
teachers are forbidden to discuss condoms? Or could it be that we will
see that decision as one taken by late-twentieth-century primitives who
compromised with witch-doctory and perished as a result?
Many people began to see the popes as poor men’s witchdoctors when
Pope Pail VI issued his encyclical
Humanae Vitae (1968), signing, some said, what was perhaps
the death warrant of humanity and making him the worst mass murderer of
all time. Paul VI allowed only the rhythm method,
described best by Catholic critics who called it "Vatican
Roulette." (from The Gay Agenda: pages 119-120).
__________________________________________________
Excerpted from The Gay Agenda: Talking Back to the
Fundamentalists, by Jack Nichols, Prometheus Books, 1996.