Google
 
Web nycny.com


GAZETTE STAFF / NEW  YORK CITY

SINKING THE REDBIRDS?

As New York City sees the 40-year old Redbird trains slowly replaced by brand-new trains, the MTA plans to have them share the fate of The RMS Titanic - to rot under the sea.

s a revenge-obsessed nation only had eyes and ears to the now-consummated State-ordered homicide(that's how they legally put it) of Timothy McVeigh, I couldn't help but notice a half-page column by Gersh Kuntzman on last Monday's edition of The New York Post.

In that article, Kuntzman mentions veteran Brooklynite Stan Fischler's campaign to preserve to posterity some the 40-year-old Redbird(the dark red cars that operate on the IRT lines)trains from a MTA-planned watery grave, as the new high-tech trains gradually take over the lines that are still, as of this writing, bravely serving the 2, 6 and 7 subway lines.

The aging fleet, which is comprised of 1,500 cars, will be taken out of service this year, and the Transport Authority plans to submerge the old but reliable cars into the ocean in an attempt to create artificial breeding grounds for fish.

In my opinion, someone in the transport authority either has water in the brain or has been eating stale sushi.

Although I do agree that it is due time to replace the old, noble trains, I do not think that the trains deserve such a sad demise. After all, they are still reliable enough to be in service.

My suggestion would be the refurbishing and sale of the trains to nations that cannot afford the state-of-the-art cars that New York is slowly receiving(we already see some of them on the 2 and 6 lines) . For example, many South American cities have ailing suburban trains that are in pitiful condition, and I do not doubt that a deal with New York to have some of the Redbirds sent there would be quite welcome, since we all know that in many states investments are desperately needed into education and roads - they need brand-new trains like a hole in the head.

Another solution would be to recycle the cars and make their metal and glass useful again in some other industry - after all, steel and glass, I believe, are recyclable. If they do that to illegal guns, why can't that be done to some of the old trains?

In Stan Fischler's opinion, the Post reported, MTA's plans are "a waste".

He is campaigning for the preservation of twenty of the soon-to-be-replaced 1,500 cars as a landmark to the history of New York subway system. His idea is to keep ten for the Transit Museum and the remaining 10 along the much-cherished 7 line to Flushing,Queens.

In this writer's opinion, the idea is not bad at all.

Many cities around the world keep historical trains running. In Brazil, there are carefully preserved steam trains that still run on occasion. In San Francisco, the old cable cars are carefully preserved and are still in service.

New York City killed the "Nostalgia Special" over twenty years ago, and now plans to send the Redbird fleet to rust in oblivion under salt water.

If Stan Fischler needs supporters to his cause, count me in.

Ernest Barteldes
Staten Island, NY

Ernest Barteldes is an ESL, GED and Portuguese teacher. In addition to that, he is a freelance writer who has been contributing to the Gazette since September 1999. His work has also been published by The Staten Island Advance, The Staten Island Register, The SI Muse,The Downtown Express, Brazzil magazine, GLSSite and other publications. He lives on Staten Island, NY. He can be reached at ebarteldes@nycny.net

READ LAST WEEK'S
STORY: CLICK HERE

A writer needs feedback in order to write properly. Please send feedback to: ebarteldes@nycny.net 
http://www.bacchin.com.br/barteldes 
Visit Ernest’s ESL Page: http://www.barteldes.freeyellow.comb 

 

Visit Poetry Magazine .com Today!
Visit Poetry Magazine .com Today!

 

Gilford Graphics

Send questions and comments to editor
To ADVERTISE in the Gazette click here
Greenwich Village Gazette Privacy Statement
Copyright © 2005 Greenwich Village Gazette. All Rights Reserved.

 


richard e. schiff,
richard

e. schiff,
 richard e. schiff
Richard Schiff
 Richard Schiff
Richard
Schiff ...

 

 

 


Recorded by
The Backhouse
Bluesers®

1988
at
Coyote Studios
Brooklyn NY

 

 

Ernest Barteldes
Current Column

Past Columns:

Music Review: "Driving Rain"
Story

John Lennon Tribute At The Real McCoy
Story

I often wonder how it felt during the Christmas of 1942, almost sixty years ago.
Story

Playin' With My Friends: Bennett sings the blues available in most record stores.
Story

Our columnist reminiscences about his first year as a New Yorker and his second as a columnist on this publication
Story

The Kansas Baxters and how their capacity to overcome tragedy helped the narrator cope with the tragic events in New York
Store

Grandma Stella has always been an example of strength to me, which I have always admired.
Story

Life has always
been difficult for
Staten Island
commuters, and
their cries have
always seemed unheard
Story

10-05-01
09-28-01
09-21-01
09-07-01
08-31-01
08-24-01
08-17-01
07-10-01
07-27-01
07-20-01
07-13-01
06-22-01
06-16-01
06-09-01
06-02-01
05-25-01
05-18-01
05-11-01
05-05-01
04-27-01
04-20-01
04-13-01
04-06-01
03-23-01
03-16-01
03-09-01
02-27-01
02-23-01
02-16-01
02-09-01
02-02-01
01-26-01
01-19-01
01-12-01
01-05-01